American Idol Top 6?

So the theme is songs of Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber.

we all know that Brooke should sing "Phantom of the Opera" and Syesha should sing "Memory"

but what song should Jason, Carly and the Davids choose??

i will listen to all answers b4 i choose best answer

American Idol Top 6?sunshine

Specifically Brooke shoud sing "All I Ask of You" from Phantom.

Jason should sing something from Joseph and the Amazing Techicolor Dreamcoat - maybe "Close Every Door".

Carly should sing something from Evita, maybe "Don't Cry for Me Argentina" or "I Don't Know how to Love Him" from Jesus Christ Superstar.

David Cook should sing "Superstar" from Jesus Christ Superstar.

David A. should sing "Any Dream will Do" from Joseph.

I love showtunes and can't wait to see what the finalists sing.

American Idol Top 6?star theater opera theater

brooke singing 'phantom of the opera' uhhh i dont think she would do that very good! syesha would probably do that better....

and i actually think the whole night is gunna be really boring!! its either gunna be that or super amazing...we shall see i guess|||hmm i dont think Brooke should sing Phantom of the Opera.. i always thought Carly would sing it, or David Cook would make it into a rock song, but maybe Brooke will make it her own, that would be fun to hear!

i hope Jason or David A sing Any Dream Will Do from Joseph. its my favorite musical!

i know and hope Syesha sings Memory from Cats, i dont want her to go home yet.

go David A and Jason!

American Idol Top 6?

Topic