Wicked- Movie based on novel or musical?

Should a Wicked: the Movie ever come out, would it be better if based on the novel and be more adult-like, or based on the musical and be family friendly? Why? I believe it would be better if based on the novel, but the musical would be a lot more viewable by younger people, who make up most of those who enjoy the series.

Wicked- Movie based on novel or musical?regal theater

I liked the musical, and I think that it tied things up in a nice little bow that the majority of the Wicked viewing audience would like to see.

However, if it were up to me, I would do the movie based on the novel... more adult, etc. The main themes that Wicked portrays are only accurately portrayed in the book. The musical touches on them (The animal rights aspect, etc) but doesn't do them justice.

Plus, I don't like to see things wrapped up in a nice package. I like to see the consequences of the characters actions!

Wicked- Movie based on novel or musical?performing art center opera theaterI definitely would base it off of the musical. If you ask me the musical with the original cast was much better than the book. If they made a movie with the original cast they would definitely have a lot of viewers! Report It |||Well the musical was great, however I think that the book would be a better source...It would be nice to see a movie out on this.

Even combining the two books into one movie could work out.|||i have not read the novel yet but i would love to see the musical version of it on the big scene

Wicked- Movie based on novel or musical?

Topic