So....who was your favorite on "Idol" tonight?

I liked Syesha(sp?) and the Davids (of course).and they both did Phantom of the Opera songs!(yay!) :)

So....who was your favorite on "Idol" tonight?pacific theater

I just watched the davids performances on youtube and archuleta did sooooooooo good! usually they are equal but he was def better 2nite!

So....who was your favorite on "Idol" tonight?phantom of the opera opera theater

The David's definetly. They will be the last two standing! I usually love Brooke but tonight I wasn't too thrilled. I like Carly though. She's getting back into the swing of things! Jason Castro need to go. A female cat song?|||I think David Cook was the best. His singing was great and his performance was amazing, as usual.

David A. was probably the second best, followed by Syesha.

Jason sang well, but it was kind of boring. Carly did great except I am bored with her and she shouts a lot when she sings.

As for Brooke... she wasn't really on point tonight...her singing was off and she forgot the lyrics.|||syesha rocked the house! but my favorite is david A.|||Favorite of the night was David Cook...even though I thought Syesha did a great job..in my opinion a first for her, since she did Mr. Jones....The Phantom songs were great tonight...minus Archie, who totally killed Think Of Me...Jason is still my favorite, but he wasnt that great tonight...I think Jason, Brooke, and Carly will be bottom three, with Brooke going home|||DAVID COOK!!! He was amazing, plus he did the song I wanted to hear him sing, so I was really happy with his performance.

I also loved Syesha, Carly and David A.

Unfortunately, though I love both Brooke and Jason, sadly one of them may go home tomorrow|||syesha and archie

So....who was your favorite on "Idol" tonight?

Topic